Comparative Study: Warehouse Pallet Rack Cyclic Testing
Home > Blog > Beam-to-Column Cyclic Testing for Warehouse Pallet Rack Failure Analysis: A Comparative Study of Roll Form and Structural Steel

Beam-to-Column Cyclic Testing for Warehouse Pallet Rack Failure Analysis: A Comparative Study of Roll Form and Structural Steel

on September 18, 2023

Warehouse pallet racks are key products used in modern supply chain management, which provide efficient storage solutions for various goods. Ensuring the structural integrity of these metal storage racks is essential to prevent potential failures that could lead to accidents, inventory loss, and disruption of operations. Beam-to-column cyclic testing is a method used to evaluate these racks’ performance and failure behavior, involving two common types of materials: roll form and structural steel. This article will help you know the process of beam-to-column cyclic testing, its significance, and the differences in testing between roll form and structural steel materials.

Beam-to-Column Cyclic Testing Process: 

Beam-to-column cyclic testing is a laboratory-based procedure designed to simulate the real-world stresses and strains that racks experience during their operational life. This testing method involves assembling representative components of a pallet rack system, including beams and columns, and subjecting them to cyclic loading that simulates the dynamic forces exerted by storage and retrieval operations. By repeatedly applying controlled loads and displacements, engineers can observe how the metal storage rack components respond, identify potential failure modes, and evaluate the rack’s overall performance under various loading scenarios.

Significance of Testing: 

Beam-to-column cyclic testing serves several crucial purposes:

Safety Assurance: Ensuring the safety of personnel and stored goods is paramount. By subjecting metal racks to cyclic loading, engineers can uncover potential failure points and assess how the system behaves as it approaches failure, allowing for necessary design improvements.

Performance Optimization: Understanding how different pallet rack components interact under cyclic loading helps optimize the metal storage rack’s design and layout to enhance its load-bearing capacity, stability, and resilience.

Regulatory Compliance: Many industries have specific regulations and standards governing rack design and safety. Cyclic testing helps manufacturers and operators comply with these standards and regulations, reducing liability risks.

Operational Reliability: Identifying failure modes and vulnerabilities through testing contributes to the long-term reliability of pallet systems, minimizing unexpected downtime and operational disruptions.

Roll Form vs. Structural Steel: 

Roll form and structural steel are two primary materials used in warehouse pallet racks. These materials exhibit different mechanical properties, manufacturing processes, and failure behaviors, influencing beam-to-column cyclic testing.

1.   Roll Form Pallet Racks:- These racks are manufactured by roll-forming steel sheets into desired shapes. They are lighter and often more cost-effective than structural steel racks. During beam-to-column cyclic testing of these racks, the following steps are typically taken:

Assembly: Rack components, including beams and columns, are assembled to create a representative section of the pallet rack.

Load Application: Cyclic loads are applied to the system through a hydraulic loading system. Load magnitudes and loading patterns can simulate various operational scenarios, such as loading and unloading goods.

Observation: Engineers monitor and record displacements, strains, and failure modes. Roll form racks tend to exhibit gradual deformation and damage accumulation before failure.

Failure Modes: Roll form racks may experience beam bending, column deformation, and connection failures. These failures often manifest as buckling, deformation, or cracking in the material.

2.   Structural Steel Pallet Racks:- Structural steel racks are constructed using heavy-duty steel members, providing greater load-bearing capacity and durability than roll form racks. The cyclic testing process for structural steel racks includes the following:

Setup: Assembling rack components to create a representative section for testing.

Loading: Applying cyclic loads using powerful hydraulic systems. These steel racks can withstand higher load amplitudes and exhibit different failure behaviors compared to roll form racks.

Analysis: Monitoring and analyzing data related to structural response, load-carrying capacity, and damage progression. Steel racks often display more elastic-plastic behavior before failure.

Failure Modes: Structural steel racks may experience plastic deformation, local buckling, and fracture in critical load-bearing components.

In brief, beam-to-column cyclic testing is a crucial methodology for evaluating warehouse racking performance and failure behavior. This testing method helps ensure these storage racking systems’ safety, reliability, and compliance by simulating real-world loading conditions. While both roll form and structural steel racks undergo similar testing processes, their distinct mechanical properties lead to different failure behaviors and modes. Manufacturers, operators, and engineers can benefit from a comprehensive understanding of beam-to-column cyclic testing to design and operate efficient and safe pallet rack systems.

Where To Go For Reliable Warehouse Pallet Racks?

This comparative analysis has helped you learn about structural steel pallet racks and roll form racks. So, now you can make your decision with better knowledge and understanding of rack systems. For companies who are looking for durable warehouse pallet rack systems, Camara Industries is the right place for you! Contact our professionals now!